Second Mate Orals: COLREG in Restricted Visibility (Rule 19) – 12 Questions
Conduct in restricted visibility is a favourite area for surveyors in the Second Mate (FG) oral exam. You may be shown a radar plot or told “you are in fog and you detect a target on your port bow” and asked what you would do and which rule says so. Many candidates lose marks by talking about stand-on and give-way vessels in fog. This set covers the questions commonly asked on Rule 19 and the related watchkeeping duties, with short model answers and the rule behind each one. Lights, shapes and fog signals, and Rules 4 to 18, are covered in separate sets.
How to use this set: read each question, answer it aloud as you would in front of the surveyor, then open the model answer to check yourself.
Questions and model answers
Q1. What is “restricted visibility”, and when are two vessels “in sight of one another”?
Restricted visibility means any condition in which visibility is restricted by fog, mist, falling snow, heavy rainstorms, sandstorms or any other similar causes, such as smoke. Vessels are deemed to be in sight of one another only when one can be observed visually from the other. Detecting a vessel on radar or AIS, or hearing her fog signal, does not mean she is in sight.
Reference: COLREG Rule 3(k) and (l)
Q2. When does Rule 19 apply, and which other steering and sailing rules apply with it?
Rule 19 applies to vessels not in sight of one another when navigating in or near an area of restricted visibility. So it can apply even when your own ship is in clear weather but the other vessel is hidden in a fog bank or a rain squall. Section I (Rules 4 to 10) applies in any condition of visibility, so look-out, safe speed, risk of collision, action to avoid collision, narrow channels and traffic separation schemes still apply. Section II (Rules 11 to 18) applies only to vessels in sight of one another. Once the other vessel comes into sight, Section II applies.
Reference: COLREG Rules 4, 11 and 19(a)
Q3. What does Rule 19(b) and (c) require, and what does “engines ready for immediate manoeuvre” mean in practice?
Every vessel must proceed at a safe speed adapted to the prevailing circumstances and conditions of restricted visibility, and a power-driven vessel must have her engines ready for immediate manoeuvre. Every vessel must also have due regard to the conditions of restricted visibility when complying with Rules 4 to 10. In practice, the engine room is informed, an unmanned machinery space is manned as per company procedures, the engine is put on manoeuvring (standby) mode so that speed can be reduced or the engine reversed without delay, and the bridge confirms this with the engine room.
Reference: COLREG Rule 19(b) and (c); Rule 6
Q4. You are OOW and visibility starts to drop. What actions do you take?
The first duty is to comply with COLREG, with particular regard to sounding fog signals, proceeding at a safe speed and having the engines ready for immediate manoeuvre. In addition, STCW requires the OOW to inform the master, post a proper look-out, exhibit navigation lights and operate and use the radar.
Good practice also includes: inform the engine room; change to hand steering with a helmsman; start radar plotting or ARPA tracking of all targets, using both radars if fitted; fix the ship’s position; close watertight doors as per company procedures; keep the bridge quiet so fog signals can be heard (open a bridge wing door if needed); and record the time, visibility, speed and actions in the deck logbook. Follow your company’s restricted visibility checklist.
Reference: STCW Code Section A-VIII/2, paragraph 45; COLREG Rules 19(b), 20(c) and 35
Q5. In fog, is there a stand-on vessel and a give-way vessel?
No. The crossing, overtaking, head-on and stand-on rules (Rules 13 to 17) are in Section II and apply only to vessels in sight of one another. Under Rule 19, every vessel that detects another by radar alone must decide whether a close-quarters situation is developing or risk of collision exists, and if so, take avoiding action herself in ample time. Both vessels have a duty to act; neither may keep her course and speed and wait for the other.
Reference: COLREG Rules 11 and 19(d)
Q6. What does Rule 19(d) say about a vessel detected by radar alone?
A vessel that detects another by radar alone must determine whether a close-quarters situation is developing and/or risk of collision exists. If so, she must take avoiding action in ample time. If the action is an alteration of course, then so far as possible she must avoid: (i) an alteration of course to port for a vessel forward of the beam, other than for a vessel being overtaken; and (ii) an alteration of course towards a vessel abeam or abaft the beam. The action must also meet Rule 8: large enough to be readily apparent on the other ship’s radar, and its effect checked until the other vessel is past and clear.
Reference: COLREG Rule 19(d); Rule 8
Q7. In fog, ARPA shows a target fine on your port bow with a steady bearing and a very small CPA. What do you do?
The target is forward of the beam, so you should not alter course to port. Call the master, and take early and substantial action: a bold alteration to starboard and/or a reduction of speed, enough to give a safe CPA and to be obvious on the other ship’s radar. Keep plotting to confirm that the CPA is opening and that the target has not altered in a way that cancels your action. If you cannot avoid a close-quarters situation with this vessel forward of the beam, Rule 19(e) applies and you must reduce to minimum steerage speed.
Reference: COLREG Rules 8, 19(d)(i) and 19(e)
Q8. A target is closing from your starboard quarter (abaft the beam) with risk of collision. What action is wrong and what can you do?
Altering course to starboard would be wrong, because it turns you towards a vessel abaft the beam. Suitable action is an alteration of course to port, away from the target, so that it passes clear astern or at a safe distance. Remember that in fog this vessel is not an “overtaking vessel” with a duty to keep clear, because Rule 13 applies only in sight; you must act yourself. Reducing speed is usually not helpful here, as it lets a vessel from astern close faster. Keep plotting until she is past and clear.
Reference: COLREG Rule 19(d)(ii)
Q9. Is there any case where you may alter to port for a vessel forward of the beam in fog?
Yes. Rule 19(d)(i) makes an exception for a vessel being overtaken. If you are coming up on a slower vessel ahead and need to pass her, you may alter to port or starboard, whichever gives the safer passing distance and keeps clear of other targets and hazards. Also note the words “so far as possible”: the rule tells you what to avoid, but navigational dangers or other traffic may limit your choices, and a reduction of speed is always an option.
Reference: COLREG Rule 19(d)(i)
Q10. You hear a fog signal apparently forward of your beam. What does Rule 19(e) require?
Except where it has been determined that risk of collision does not exist, a vessel that hears the fog signal of another vessel apparently forward of her beam, or that cannot avoid a close-quarters situation with a vessel forward of her beam, must reduce her speed to the minimum at which she can be kept on her course. If necessary she must take all her way off, and in any event navigate with extreme caution until the danger of collision is over. The direction of a sound in fog can be misleading, so do not rely on it to judge the other vessel’s position.
Reference: COLREG Rule 19(e)
Q11. Do the “not to impede” duties in narrow channels and traffic separation schemes still apply in fog?
Yes. Rules 9 and 10 are in Section I and apply in any condition of visibility. A small vessel, sailing vessel or fishing vessel must still not impede a vessel that can navigate safely only within a narrow channel or that is following a traffic lane. Rule 8(f) also applies: the vessel required not to impede must act early, and if risk of collision develops, both vessels must comply with the steering and sailing rules, which in fog means Rule 19.
Reference: COLREG Rules 4, 8(f), 9 and 10
Q12. What are the dangers of relying on radar and AIS in restricted visibility?
Small craft, wooden boats, ice and floating objects may not be detected by radar in time, especially in sea or rain clutter. Targets can be lost in blind sectors or shadow areas. Decisions made on scanty radar information, such as a single observation, can be badly wrong, so systematic plotting over time is needed. Not every vessel carries AIS or has it switched on, and AIS data such as heading, course and position may be wrong or delayed. AIS can help identify a target, but avoiding action should be based on a full appraisal using radar plotting, look-out by sight and hearing, and all other available means.
Reference: COLREG Rules 5, 6(b) and 7(b) and (c)
Quick self-test
Choose your answer, then tap “Show answer” to check.
1. Rule 19 applies to vessels: (a) in sight of one another in fog (b) not in sight of one another in or near an area of restricted visibility (c) only inside a fog bank (d) only when both have radar
Answer: (b) Not in sight of one another when navigating in or near an area of restricted visibility (Rule 19(a)).
2. In fog, a target detected by radar alone is forward of your beam on the port bow with risk of collision. So far as possible you should avoid: (a) reducing speed (b) altering course to starboard (c) altering course to port (d) sounding fog signals
Answer: (c) Avoid an alteration to port for a vessel forward of the beam, other than one being overtaken (Rule 19(d)(i)).
3. You hear a fog signal apparently forward of the beam and have not determined that there is no risk of collision. You must: (a) increase speed to clear the area (b) reduce to the minimum speed at which you can keep your course (c) alter course towards the sound (d) maintain course and speed as the stand-on vessel
Answer: (b) Reduce to minimum steerage speed, take all way off if necessary, and navigate with extreme caution (Rule 19(e)).
4. Which of these is NOT one of the OOW’s additional duties listed in STCW when restricted visibility is encountered? (a) inform the master (b) post a proper look-out (c) exhibit navigation lights (d) switch off the radar to reduce clutter
Answer: (d) STCW requires the OOW to operate and use the radar, not switch it off (STCW Code A-VIII/2, para 45).
5. Vessels are deemed to be in sight of one another when: (a) both appear on radar (b) one can hear the other’s fog signal (c) one can be observed visually from the other (d) both are on AIS
Answer: (c) Only when one can be observed visually from the other (Rule 3(k)).
Disclaimer: These questions and model answers are study aids written by CrewMirror, not official examination questions or answers. Please check the current text of COLREG and the latest DGMA examination requirements before your exam. CrewMirror and its owners and operators will not be responsible for any loss or damage caused by the use of information published on CrewMirror pages and posts.
This article was prepared with the help of Internet Search and AI assistance tools.











