Indian marine engineers checking a lube oil sample beside the purifier in a ship's engine room

Second Engineer Orals: Lube Oil Quality and Crankcase Safety – 11 Questions

Surveyors in the Second Engineer (MEO Class II) oral exam often move from crankcase explosions straight to the lubricating oil itself: what goes wrong with system oil, how you find out, and whether poor oil can lead to an explosion. This set covers the lube oil questions candidates are commonly asked, with short model answers you can say in your own words.

Some questions in this set were shared by candidates after their exam.

How to use this set: read each question, answer it aloud as you would in front of the surveyor, then open the model answer to check yourself.

Questions and model answers

Q1. Does lube oil quality have any influence on crankcase explosions? If yes, how?

Yes, but mostly indirectly. A crankcase explosion needs a hot spot and an oil mist in the explosive range. Poor oil quality makes a hot spot more likely: low viscosity (from fuel dilution or overheating), water contamination, oxidation and sludge, or dirt and wear particles can break down the oil film, so a bearing, crosshead or piston runs hot and starts to wipe or seize. That hot spot then vaporises the oil and produces the mist.

Fuel dilution also lowers the oil’s flash point, so vapour forms more easily. However, tests show the auto-ignition temperature of the oil falls much less than the flash point, and moderate dilution alone does not normally cause an explosion. A good answer is: poor oil quality is a contributing factor, mainly because it leads to hot spots, which is why oil condition, temperature and purification are watched closely.

Q2. Why is the flash point of system oil checked, and what does a fall in flash point tell you?

Flash point is the lowest temperature at which the oil gives off enough vapour to flash when a flame is applied. A fall in flash point is the standard indicator that the system oil is contaminated with fuel. It means the oil gives off flammable vapour more easily and its lubricating properties are also reduced. Find and stop the source (for example leaking fuel equipment or blow-by on a trunk piston engine) and compare the result with the minimum given in your engine maker’s lube oil guidance.

Q3. What can cause the viscosity of system oil to rise or fall?
Q4. How can water get into the main engine system oil, and why is it harmful?

Common sources are leaks from the piston cooling or jacket cooling system, a leaking lube oil cooler (sea water or fresh water side), condensation in the sump or tanks, a wrongly operated purifier (water seal or operating water carried over), and leaking heating coils in the sump tank.

Water causes corrosion of bearing materials and journals, forms emulsions that weaken the oil film, depletes additives, encourages sludge and bacterial growth, and can block filters. Sea water is worse because the salt is very corrosive. Engine makers set a maximum water content for used oil; for example, one major maker’s guidance for its four-stroke engines allows a maximum of 0.2%, or 0.5% for short periods. Always use the limit for your own engine.

Q5. How would you check for water in the system oil on board?

Look at the oil sample: a cloudy or milky appearance suggests water. Use the on-board test kit (water-in-oil test) if fitted. A simple crackle test on a hot plate also shows free water. Watch for supporting signs: a rise in sump tank level, a drop in cooling water expansion tank level, water discharged at the purifier, or a change in cooling water chemistry. If sea water is suspected, a chloride check on the separated water helps. Confirm with a laboratory analysis.

Q6. On a crosshead engine, the BN of the system oil is rising. What does this indicate?

System oil on a crosshead engine has a fairly low BN, while cylinder oil has a much higher BN. A steady rise in system oil BN (often with a rise in viscosity and insolubles) suggests that cylinder oil and scavenge space drainings are getting into the crankcase, usually because of worn or leaking piston rod stuffing box rings. Check the stuffing box drain amounts, inspect and overhaul the stuffing box as per the maker’s instructions, and keep monitoring the oil.

Q7. How can fuel get into the lubricating oil, and how do you confirm it?

On trunk piston engines (generators), unburnt fuel can be carried into the crankcase by blow-by past worn or stuck rings, poor atomisation from leaking injectors, or leaks from fuel pumps and pipes inside the engine. On crosshead engines, contamination usually comes with scavenge drainings through a leaking stuffing box. Fuel contamination is confirmed by a fall in flash point and, for distillate fuel, a fall in viscosity. Laboratory analysis can also show the percentage of fuel.

Q8. What does a shore laboratory analysis of system oil normally report?

Typical parameters are viscosity, flash point, water content, BN (and sometimes acid number), insolubles, and elements. Wear metals such as iron, copper, tin, lead and aluminium point to wear of particular parts. Sodium with water suggests sea water. Aluminium and silicon together suggest catalytic fines from the fuel. The results must be read together and as a trend, not one figure alone. Samples are usually sent about every three months, or as per the maker’s and company’s schedule, and always taken from the same point with the engine running.

See also  Second Engineer Orals: Crankcase Explosions and Oil Mist Detectors – 10 Questions
Q9. Why must the lube oil temperature be controlled? What happens if it runs too hot?

Hot oil has a lower viscosity, so the oil film in the bearings becomes thinner. It also oxidises faster, forming acids and sludge, and it gives off more vapour, which increases the oil mist in the crankcase. Typical causes are a fouled cooler, a faulty thermostatic valve, low cooling water flow or a hot bearing. Keep the oil inlet temperature within the range in the engine maker’s manual.

Q10. How does the lube oil purifier help keep the system oil in good condition?

The purifier runs continuously on the sump (bypass cleaning) and removes water, sludge, soot and solid particles that the full-flow filters cannot hold. For good separation, keep the correct throughput (a lower flow gives better cleaning), the correct heating temperature, the right gravity disc or setting for the oil, and regular desludging and overhaul as per the maker’s instructions. Watch the water outlet and sludge discharge, because an increase is an early warning of contamination.

Q11. Apart from lubrication, what other jobs does the system oil do in a main engine?

It cools bearings and, on many engines, the pistons; it carries away dirt and wear particles to the filters and purifier; it protects surfaces against corrosion; it helps neutralise acids; and on many engines it is also used as the hydraulic or control oil (for example, for exhaust valve actuation or the hydraulic system on electronically controlled engines). This is why the whole system depends on keeping the oil clean and within limits.

Quick self-test

Choose your answer, then tap “Show answer” to check.

1. A fall in the flash point of system oil usually indicates: (a) water contamination (b) fuel contamination (c) oxidation (d) high BN

Answer: (b) Fuel dilution lowers the flash point.

2. Rising BN in a crosshead engine’s system oil most likely means: (a) a leaking cooler (b) a leaking piston rod stuffing box (c) a dirty purifier (d) low oil temperature

Answer: (b) High-BN cylinder oil drainings are entering the crankcase.

3. Aluminium and silicon found together in an oil analysis suggest: (a) sea water (b) catalytic fines (c) bearing wear only (d) fuel dilution
See also  Second Engineer Orals: Crankcase Explosions and Oil Mist Detectors – 10 Questions

Answer: (b) Catalytic fines carried over from the fuel.

4. Poor lube oil quality contributes to crankcase explosions mainly by: (a) raising crankcase pressure (b) causing hot spots through oil film breakdown (c) blocking relief valves (d) cooling the crankcase

Answer: (b) Film breakdown leads to hot bearings, which create the mist and ignition source.

5. A fall in system oil viscosity is most commonly caused by: (a) soot (b) oxidation (c) dilution with distillate fuel (d) cylinder oil contamination

Answer: (c) Lighter distillate fuel thins the oil.

Disclaimer: These questions and model answers are study aids written by CrewMirror, not official examination questions or answers. Always follow your engine maker’s instructions and your company’s procedures, and check the current SOLAS, IACS and classification society requirements and the latest DGMA examination requirements before your exam. CrewMirror and its owners and operators will not be responsible for any loss or damage caused by the use of information published on CrewMirror pages and posts.

Looking for a job at sea? Find the latest maritime vacancies and apply to companies of your choice on WhatsApp with WhatsMate.

This article was prepared with the help of Internet Search and AI assistance tools.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eight + 15 =