P&I Club Highlights Philippine Ruling on Seafarer Disability Assessments
Japan P&I Club has issued a circular, dated 16 November 2026, highlighting a ruling by the Philippines’ Supreme Court in Manila on how disability claims by Filipino seafarers should be judged. The ruling itself was handed down on 27 January 2026.
The case involved an oiler who injured his left knee on board in May 2018 and was repatriated for surgery and rehabilitation under a company-designated doctor. That doctor declared him fit to work on day 123 after repatriation, while a doctor chosen by the seafarer found him permanently unfit for sea duty. Labour arbitrators and the Court of Appeals awarded him permanent and total disability benefits.
From the CrewMirror Blog
The Supreme Court reversed those decisions. Under Philippine rules, the company doctor normally has 120 days to issue a final assessment, which can be extended to 240 days when further treatment is needed. The court held that the extension was justified because the medical records showed continuing symptoms and the need for more rehabilitation. It added that conflicting medical opinions should be weighed by the evidence behind them, not just their conclusions.
The club notes that the new Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers says disability pay should not depend only on the length of treatment, and how this fits existing case law is still unsettled. P&I clubs often handle such claims, and Filipino unions have recently agreed to work more closely with the government on seafarer welfare and case handling.
CrewMirror Takeaway
Seafarers repatriated for medical treatment should keep copies of every medical record and report, because courts now look closely at the evidence behind each doctor’s opinion, not only at the timing of the assessment.














